Xbox auto-signs in the wrong controller

[Pumpkinempanada]

Maybe someone can help me. I have two Xbox controllers, and I keep one plugged in and charging while the other one I use to play. The problem is that lately some games seem to sign me into my live account on the other controller, the one plugged in. It does this even though I turn on the Xbox by holding down the button on the free controller.

 

It did it on Borderlands and now it's doing it with Halo 4. I have to manually go back out to the dashboard, sign out, then sign back in again every time I play.

 

Anyone know how to fix this? I could unplug the other controller, but it should work. The problem has only been happening the last few months.

 

Thanks

Bob

[Sarge]

log onto your first controller then plug in your second.

[Pumpkinempanada]

Yeah but I don't want to be unplugging an replugging a controller every time I sit down. I doubt most people do that?

[Arctic Vortex]

I don't know... try calling Xbox Support.

[mazer]

settings: preferences: auto sign in: undo auto sign in.

[Fox McCloud]

^That's right.

[l Xenoes l]

Have this problem and I don't know how to fix it or make it so it doesn't make my other controller first player. I always just unplug it to keep this from happening.