Jump to content

Star Wars vs. Halo


ZB-85

Recommended Posts

Miniamp brought up an interesting topic about:

 

If a worm hole opened up between the Halo and Star Wars universe, and they started fighting each other. Who would win?

Timeline: Halo CEA. Star Wars 3

 

Discuss...

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Assuming that all forces of Halo fought all the forces of Star Wars, I'd have to say Star Wars. The size of the empire rivals that of the Covenant, and considering they have a cloning facility( eugh, prequel references *throws up*) they'd have an endless supply of Troops.

And, we have to take into account the biggest tide turner, the force. Assuming the ability still existed when the wormhole opened, the jedi and sith would be able to use the force on everything, meaning they can manipulate things.

This is a really basic summary, and could probably go into uber detail, but eh.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

halo, simply because they have an almost endless amount of man power and machinery, (Covenant Armadas a few million strong)

Since it's the entire Universe, the flood and Forruner objects would be unlocked. The only true oppenet would be a death star, which a few dozen Super Macs should be able to rip it apart

 

And I feel we would of Space superiority with Forruner ships.

We could destroy planets VIA glassing/ plasma bombardment in hours.

 

 

 

would be a close ass fight, but I feel halo would come out with its head held victorious

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Depends on when the attack happened. If they started fighting at the end of Halo 3, then definitely Star Wars because the Covenant was mostly disbanded and the UNSC was still wasted after the Battle of Earth and the Fall of Reach. Any other time then that, I'd have to say Halo because the Covenant would put up a tough fight.

 

Edit: The UNSC would also probably team up with the Covenant. A smart AI (like Cortana) could use the plasma cannons on the Covenant ship to cut through almost anything. Halo for the win! :yahoo:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

halo, simply because they have an almost endless amount of man power and machinery, (Covenant Armadas a few million strong)

Since it's the entire Universe, the flood and Forruner objects would be unlocked. The only true oppenet would be a death star, which a few dozen Super Macs should be able to rip it apart

 

And I feel we would of Space superiority with Forruner ships.

We could destroy planets VIA glassing/ plasma bombardment in hours.

 

 

 

would be a close ass fight, but I feel halo would come out with its head held victorious

 

Well....hmmm...yeah. I agree. If the entire Halo-multiverse teamed up they'd destroy the Jedi.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

*sigh*

 

Lets compare their technology:

 

aircraft: the covenants seemingly most advanced airborne fighter the banshee is slower, more poorly armed, less maneuverable, and less heavily armed than the cheap snow speeder in star-wars, and in the star wars universe the snow speeder is basically cannon fodder against an imperial forces. Dedicated aerospace fighters are way above anything the covenant has, and they have them in absolutely massive numbers.

 

armored vehicles: the covenant tanks (spectre) seem to have roughly the armor and weaponry of basic police land speeders, nothing compared to advanced military tanks and walkers used by the empire

 

flying bikes: the ghost is slower, less maneuverable, and no better armed than the run-of-the-mill bikes in star wars, and would be torn to shred by even the most basic land speeder

 

capital ships: star wars has tens of thousands of star destroyers. Even the smaller star destroyers are capable of not only killing all life on a planet, but blasting away the entire atmosphere and melting the surface in under a day, and probably more like an hour to prevent enemy defensive forces from arriving. And these are regular imperial battleships (which they have tens of thousands of), not the most massive ones. And the Death Star may be cheap to use, but they have built two and several other variants with the same destructive ability, so it cannot be neglected. And even with the ability to sterilize a planet, melt its surface, and blast away the entire atmosphere, a group of several star destroyers was still not able to penetrate a realtively small, make-shift shield on Hoth. Also, the shield on Alderaan was able to protect the entire planet from the Death Star for a fraction of a second, so it would likely be no trivial matter for the covenenant to penetrate imperial shields. The covenant cannot use the HALO network because it would kill them as well. It destroys all macroscopic life in the galaxy. Besides, the imperial hyperdrives can cross the galaxy in a matter of a few days or even less, and the HALO space stations are easily destroyed, the imperial forces would probably have little trouble capturing one, using it to determine the location of the others, and destroying them all.

 

ground weapons: Covenant weapons either use ammo or easily overheat. Their rifle-sized weapons also take multiple shots to take down even unarmored humans. On the other hand imperial pistols can take down an armored storm trooper or robot in one shot, while their carbines are capable of blowing small holes in walls and their larger rifles are capable of destroying armored vehicles (so more powerful than the HALO rocket launchers). Their crew-served two-person machine gunes are capable of taking out a small transport ship, while their self-propelled missile tanks can take out large starships. This is opposed to HALO's wraith, an armored, self-propelled mortar that can't even kill a human in one shot. Star Wars also has thermal detonators, which are far more destructive even than covenant plasma grenades, powerful enough that an entire large room full of people were afraid of it while the HALO grenades only have a destructive radius of maybe two meters, three at most, and even then isn't necessarily lethal. Plasma swords look cool, but they cannot penetrate shields, walls, and take several hits to penetrate armor. There is no comparison with light sabers or even vibra-blades in star wars, which can kill armored foes instantly. The very fact that blade weapons without any defensive ability are effective weapons for ordinary soldiers indicates just how poor the projectile weapons are. In terms of accuracy, in the battle of Hoth and the battle in Geonosia they were exchanging gun fire and scoring direct hits at a range of several kilometers.

 

combat: the covenant may be religious zealots, but they do not seem particularly bright nor are they particularly brave, with the grunts running away routinely. The imperial forces are smart enough to set traps and trick and mislead their opponents. They also seldom, if ever, run away, even willingly sacrificing themselves for a simple trap, and are conditioned well enough that they have absolutely no problem destroying all life on a neutral, totally civilian planet, or destroying the planet entirely.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

halo, simply because they have an almost endless amount of man power and machinery, (Covenant Armadas a few million strong)

Since it's the entire Universe, the flood and Forruner objects would be unlocked. The only true oppenet would be a death star, which a few dozen Super Macs should be able to rip it apart

 

And I feel we would of Space superiority with Forruner ships.

We could destroy planets VIA glassing/ plasma bombardment in hours.

 

 

 

would be a close ass fight, but I feel halo would come out with its head held victorious

But then that becomes an unknown fight, who knows what other creatures and tech exist in the Star Wars universe, there could be beings of pure force, able to move planets. For a good conclusion confinement is needed.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

*sigh*

 

Lets compare their technology:

 

aircraft: the covenants seemingly most advanced airborne fighter the banshee is slower, more poorly armed, less maneuverable, and less heavily armed than the cheap snow speeder in star-wars, and in the star wars universe the snow speeder is basically cannon fodder against an imperial forces. Dedicated aerospace fighters are way above anything the covenant has, and they have them in absolutely massive numbers.

 

armored vehicles: the covenant tanks (spectre) seem to have roughly the armor and weaponry of basic police land speeders, nothing compared to advanced military tanks and walkers used by the empire

 

flying bikes: the ghost is slower, less maneuverable, and no better armed than the run-of-the-mill bikes in star wars, and would be torn to shred by even the most basic land speeder

 

capital ships: star wars has tens of thousands of star destroyers. Even the smaller star destroyers are capable of not only killing all life on a planet, but blasting away the entire atmosphere and melting the surface in under a day, and probably more like an hour to prevent enemy defensive forces from arriving. And these are regular imperial battleships (which they have tens of thousands of), not the most massive ones. And the Death Star may be cheap to use, but they have built two and several other variants with the same destructive ability, so it cannot be neglected. And even with the ability to sterilize a planet, melt its surface, and blast away the entire atmosphere, a group of several star destroyers was still not able to penetrate a realtively small, make-shift shield on Hoth. Also, the shield on Alderaan was able to protect the entire planet from the Death Star for a fraction of a second, so it would likely be no trivial matter for the covenenant to penetrate imperial shields. The covenant cannot use the HALO network because it would kill them as well. It destroys all macroscopic life in the galaxy. Besides, the imperial hyperdrives can cross the galaxy in a matter of a few days or even less, and the HALO space stations are easily destroyed, the imperial forces would probably have little trouble capturing one, using it to determine the location of the others, and destroying them all.

 

ground weapons: Covenant weapons either use ammo or easily overheat. Their rifle-sized weapons also take multiple shots to take down even unarmored humans. On the other hand imperial pistols can take down an armored storm trooper or robot in one shot, while their carbines are capable of blowing small holes in walls and their larger rifles are capable of destroying armored vehicles (so more powerful than the HALO rocket launchers). Their crew-served two-person machine gunes are capable of taking out a small transport ship, while their self-propelled missile tanks can take out large starships. This is opposed to HALO's wraith, an armored, self-propelled mortar that can't even kill a human in one shot. Star Wars also has thermal detonators, which are far more destructive even than covenant plasma grenades, powerful enough that an entire large room full of people were afraid of it while the HALO grenades only have a destructive radius of maybe two meters, three at most, and even then isn't necessarily lethal. Plasma swords look cool, but they cannot penetrate shields, walls, and take several hits to penetrate armor. There is no comparison with light sabers or even vibra-blades in star wars, which can kill armored foes instantly. The very fact that blade weapons without any defensive ability are effective weapons for ordinary soldiers indicates just how poor the projectile weapons are. In terms of accuracy, in the battle of Hoth and the battle in Geonosia they were exchanging gun fire and scoring direct hits at a range of several kilometers.

 

combat: the covenant may be religious zealots, but they do not seem particularly bright nor are they particularly brave, with the grunts running away routinely. The imperial forces are smart enough to set traps and trick and mislead their opponents. They also seldom, if ever, run away, even willingly sacrificing themselves for a simple trap, and are conditioned well enough that they have absolutely no problem destroying all life on a neutral, totally civilian planet, or destroying the planet entirely.

Based on this Star Wars could destroy Halo. :(

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Honestly, if starwars started to win, we would activate the halo arrays, which would kill us both, or we would hide in shield worlds

 

worst case scenario, it's either a tie, or we virtually nuke the galaxy

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Honestly, if starwars started to win, we would activate the halo arrays, which would kill us both, or we would hide in shield worlds

 

worst case scenario, it's either a tie, or we virtually nuke the galaxy

Lol, there are so many possibilities. I'd say nuke the galaxy :thumbsup:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

*sigh*

 

Lets compare their technology:

 

aircraft: the covenants seemingly most advanced airborne fighter the banshee is slower, more poorly armed, less maneuverable, and less heavily armed than the cheap snow speeder in star-wars, and in the star wars universe the snow speeder is basically cannon fodder against an imperial forces. Dedicated aerospace fighters are way above anything the covenant has, and they have them in absolutely massive numbers.

 

armored vehicles: the covenant tanks (spectre) seem to have roughly the armor and weaponry of basic police land speeders, nothing compared to advanced military tanks and walkers used by the empire

 

flying bikes: the ghost is slower, less maneuverable, and no better armed than the run-of-the-mill bikes in star wars, and would be torn to shred by even the most basic land speeder

 

capital ships: star wars has tens of thousands of star destroyers. Even the smaller star destroyers are capable of not only killing all life on a planet, but blasting away the entire atmosphere and melting the surface in under a day, and probably more like an hour to prevent enemy defensive forces from arriving. And these are regular imperial battleships (which they have tens of thousands of), not the most massive ones. And the Death Star may be cheap to use, but they have built two and several other variants with the same destructive ability, so it cannot be neglected. And even with the ability to sterilize a planet, melt its surface, and blast away the entire atmosphere, a group of several star destroyers was still not able to penetrate a realtively small, make-shift shield on Hoth. Also, the shield on Alderaan was able to protect the entire planet from the Death Star for a fraction of a second, so it would likely be no trivial matter for the covenenant to penetrate imperial shields. The covenant cannot use the HALO network because it would kill them as well. It destroys all macroscopic life in the galaxy. Besides, the imperial hyperdrives can cross the galaxy in a matter of a few days or even less, and the HALO space stations are easily destroyed, the imperial forces would probably have little trouble capturing one, using it to determine the location of the others, and destroying them all.

 

ground weapons: Covenant weapons either use ammo or easily overheat. Their rifle-sized weapons also take multiple shots to take down even unarmored humans. On the other hand imperial pistols can take down an armored storm trooper or robot in one shot, while their carbines are capable of blowing small holes in walls and their larger rifles are capable of destroying armored vehicles (so more powerful than the HALO rocket launchers). Their crew-served two-person machine gunes are capable of taking out a small transport ship, while their self-propelled missile tanks can take out large starships. This is opposed to HALO's wraith, an armored, self-propelled mortar that can't even kill a human in one shot. Star Wars also has thermal detonators, which are far more destructive even than covenant plasma grenades, powerful enough that an entire large room full of people were afraid of it while the HALO grenades only have a destructive radius of maybe two meters, three at most, and even then isn't necessarily lethal. Plasma swords look cool, but they cannot penetrate shields, walls, and take several hits to penetrate armor. There is no comparison with light sabers or even vibra-blades in star wars, which can kill armored foes instantly. The very fact that blade weapons without any defensive ability are effective weapons for ordinary soldiers indicates just how poor the projectile weapons are. In terms of accuracy, in the battle of Hoth and the battle in Geonosia they were exchanging gun fire and scoring direct hits at a range of several kilometers.

 

combat: the covenant may be religious zealots, but they do not seem particularly bright nor are they particularly brave, with the grunts running away routinely. The imperial forces are smart enough to set traps and trick and mislead their opponents. They also seldom, if ever, run away, even willingly sacrificing themselves for a simple trap, and are conditioned well enough that they have absolutely no problem destroying all life on a neutral, totally civilian planet, or destroying the planet entirely.

 

this, plus the scale of the star wars universe is huge compared to halo so they have the numbers advantage. plus star wars has way mores know sentient species compared to halo. and the flood wouldn't be much of a threat to star wars as they can easily incinerate a planet wiping out the flood. so my vote goes to star wars

Link to comment
Share on other sites

well if everyone in halo vs everyone in star wars fought halo would win because think about theres master cheif weighs like 1000lbs can kill pretty much anything and theres the covenant, unsc, flood taking over all the jedi, precurors who have power behond jedi with the force, forerunner with their amazing, technology, weapons like the spartan lazer which is 1 shot one kill, and armor abillities

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 8 months later...

It's an insult to both series to imagine them fighting each other. They are both classics that deserve our respect, however....

 

At the time of "Star Wars 3", which I am going to take as the Revenge of the Sith, there aren't that many Jedis left. So their supernatural powers are not really relevant. They don't have the Death Star yet, so you don't need to factor that in either. In all honesty, the ground vehicles in Star Wars are lamentably impractical for actual combat as well.

 

The heroes of Halo would undoubtedly win. The fact that such a small rebellion could even survive in the Empire shows that it wasn't terribly power, pre-Death Star.

 

We can summarize the conflict as such: Master Chief vs. Darth Vader (at this point Anakin, whatever)

 

How different are lightsabers and energy swords? How many times has Master Chief killed an Elite with an Energy Sword?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...