Jump to content

  •  

Toggle shoutbox 343i Community Shoutbox

@  Halo6 Follower : (13 December 2019 - 08:42 PM) Have a good day at work though!
@  Halo6 Follower : (13 December 2019 - 08:42 PM) Ouch
@  Vitamin Pwn : (13 December 2019 - 02:30 PM) Not much enjoying my Friday morning before I have to work
@  Halo6 Follower : (13 December 2019 - 05:31 AM) You??
@  Halo6 Follower : (13 December 2019 - 05:31 AM) Not much on my end! Just enjoying a Friday night :D
@  Vitamin Pwn : (12 December 2019 - 11:45 PM) What’s up you cool babies?
@  343iBot : (12 December 2019 - 01:10 PM) Welcome to the forums, antsilva! :welcome: View antsilva's Profile
@  UNSC Spartan-II : (11 December 2019 - 05:04 PM) @Mothy Need to go dig that up now
@  343iBot : (11 December 2019 - 10:18 AM) Welcome to the forums, HapunrU! :welcome: View HapunrU's Profile
@  343iBot : (10 December 2019 - 11:44 PM) Welcome to the forums, dubstepx41! :welcome: View dubstepx41's Profile
@  343iBot : (10 December 2019 - 07:06 PM) Welcome to the forums, Penguin Space! :welcome: View Penguin Space's Profile
@  Halo6 Follower : (10 December 2019 - 06:08 AM) Blast from the past
@  Halo6 Follower : (10 December 2019 - 06:08 AM) Wow yeah
@  Mothy : (10 December 2019 - 03:37 AM) Anyone remember the 343i community yearbook? Yea, I dont want to either smh
@  Mothy : (10 December 2019 - 03:22 AM) Shoutboxington
@  Mothy : (10 December 2019 - 03:22 AM) How are things in Shoutland
@  Mothy : (10 December 2019 - 03:21 AM) Hola hombres
@  Mothy : (10 December 2019 - 03:21 AM) @KhevaKins I sure did, im not rushing to rebuy a game ive been playing for eight years though
@  343iBot : (09 December 2019 - 04:01 PM) Welcome to the forums, EdwardVal! :welcome: View EdwardVal's Profile
@  343iBot : (09 December 2019 - 08:34 AM) Welcome to the forums, Mikaelaerop! :welcome: View Mikaelaerop's Profile

Photo

Halo TV Show

Halo TV Show Time Controversy Cast

  • Please log in to reply
2 replies to this topic

#1 KhevaKins

KhevaKins

    Elite

  • Members
  • 86 posts
58
Liked
  • Gamertag:KhevaKins
  • LocationQueensland Australia

Posted 11 November 2019 - 05:25 AM

Early days, to be sure, but what are everyone's feelings on the show so far?

For context here are some links:

Halo Showtime Facebook

Halo Cast IMDB

Latest Press Release Variety.com

Little Bit Of Controversy Explained Screen Rant

 

I guess I'll just go bullet point:

 

Jacob And Miranda Keyes

Why even have them in the show?

Let alone to so fundamentally change the characters?
And I am not (just) talking about the racial bending.
"Gray will play Dr. Miranda Keyes, a brilliant UNSC Commander who is dedicated to understanding the technology, language and culture of the Covenant, but she’ll have to learn to navigate the politics of the UNSC to get what she wants."
In the established canon Miranda is accept to Luna Officer Candidate School at age 16, graduates with honors then immediate requests active duty (because, you know, we are at war with the Covvies at this point).

At what point in time would she of had time to go and get a Doctorate? There are programs where you can get a PHD while on active military duty, but at no point has it been mentioned that Miranda had one.

 

"Sapani will play Captain Jacob Keyes, described a dedicated military man, a war hero and a caring father. He finds that working alongside his daughter and his ex-wife is usually the cause of conflict rather than comfort."
Alongside daughter, ok, makes a little sense (maybe, but not really), but ex-wife? Jacob hadn't seen Halsey from years 2530 (ish) to 2552, 22 years. And then they were only together like a day. Halsey didn't see him again because he died on Halo. So how exactly does he work 'alongside' her? They are trying to somehow spin a story where in an galactic war for survival these three people are entwined? Jacob and Miranda have a good relationship but as far as I can tell they were both Bridge Crew on different ships in different fleets? Not a lot of opportunity for cooperation, at least not personally between them.

 

Plus, they have been portrayed as African descent, which I don't really care about but why not just write two new characters? This portrayal seems to be completely different to anything established to the point where they are new characters, but then to change their race as well? For canon nerds it is definitely irritating.

 

 

Makee

 

"Murphy will play Makee, an orphaned human who was raised by the alien Covenant and shares their contempt for humanity"

A new character written for the show.
Is this a joke?
Not only does it fundamentally undermine the entire goal of the Covenant Crusade (complete eradication), but it is pretty clique writing that has been done tonnes of time, and probably better.

There are a few cases of humans and Covvies working together (Mona Lisa, The Rubble) but to be 'raised' by the Covvies? If this is the quality of writing for the show we can expect, we are gonna have a bad time.

 

Side Notes

If they don't have Steve Downes dubbing John-117's voice, then why even have the big MC in the show?

Same kind of goes for Jen Taylor doing the voice, but I do think Natascha McElhone   could be a cool mo-cap actor for Cortana, although I think Jen Taylor also would of been cool as I can envision both as her avatar. It would be cool if Natasha did Halsey, then Jen Taylor dubbed Cortana.

 

Soren-066 played by Bokeem Woodbine  could be cool, although if they are doing post augmentation (which they kind of have to), then Soren is all kinds of messed up? I guess they will go into what happens to him.

 

Vannak-134 sounds lame. "serves as the defacto deputy to the Master Chief." What does that even mean? I get it couldn't be Fred yet, because he is still leading his own team, but Vannak? There are so many established S-IIs they could of used they wasted one of their spots on a sidekick for Chief? Put MF Jorge in as having served with MC before Noble Team. Would of been way cooler.

 

Also, no casting for any Covvie characters as yet? Kind of disappointing.

 

 

 

I honestly, and sincerely, hope the show will be good. Unfortunately Halo just hasn't got a good track record of having good video extended media (FUD, Legends, Nightfall, Fall of Reach). They have all fallen short of being satisfactory in almost any regard. They really need to have someone watching over the Extended Media as a whole and making sure everything lines up. They may not want to have to keep following the Canon from the 18 year old original books but Fall Of Reach (the book) continues to be one of the most popular of all the books, and is sold not only as add-on for the games but as just a very good sci-fi book in general.


"Soundwave Superior. Constructions Inferior"


#2 Tommy

Tommy

    パa�ナップル

  • Legendary Members
  • 942 posts
334
Dedicated
  • Gamertag:Pantsu
  • LocationIllinois, USA
                 

Posted 11 November 2019 - 06:02 PM

I'm not sure I fully agree with the previous films being dissapointing. I for one enjoyed Legends, and Forward unto Dawn tremendously.

 

When it comes to the new show coming out, I believe that Microsoft will put as much funding into it as they need to make it successful. This show is a big deal in the gaming world and will be combed through with a very very fine comb, and everyone involved knows it.



#3 KhevaKins

KhevaKins

    Elite

  • Members
  • 86 posts
58
Liked
  • Gamertag:KhevaKins
  • LocationQueensland Australia

Posted 07 December 2019 - 08:59 AM

I'm not sure I fully agree with the previous films being dissapointing. I for one enjoyed Legends, and Forward unto Dawn tremendously.

 

When it comes to the new show coming out, I believe that Microsoft will put as much funding into it as they need to make it successful. This show is a big deal in the gaming world and will be combed through with a very very fine comb, and everyone involved knows it.

 

They tend to be watchable despite themselves.

Legends, the stories are cool and (mainly) fit into canon, but the varying art-styles are so jarring. I know they said the visuals aren't necessarily canon (teen Halsey?) but the stories are?

 

Forward Unto Dawn, teen actors are subpar.

Nightfall, generic and boring. Visually it looks just like another generic "Syfy channel movie". You know the ones.

 

Halo Fall Of Reach, they took what is arguably everyone favorite book and retold it based on someones memory of the story? Like they just had someone sit down, read it once, then wrote the script based on what that one dude remembered. Also, the CGI works in the hidden logs in the games, as they are just little one and a half minute snippets expanding on lore, but the artstyle just doesn't hold up over a 1 hour movie.

 


"Soundwave Superior. Constructions Inferior"






1 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users